Looking for a fun and easy back-to-school snack that is almost too cute to eat? These Pencil Wafer Cookies are the perfect sweet treat for the first day of school, lunchboxes, classroom parties, teacher appreciation gifts, or an after-school surprise.
Made with simple store-bought wafer cookies and candy melts, these adorable pencil-shaped treats come together quickly and require no baking. They are a great option for busy moms who want to make the back-to-school season feel a little more special without spending hours in the kitchen.
Why You’ll Love These Pencil Wafer Cookies
These back-to-school cookies are:
Easy to make
No-bake
Kid-friendly
Perfect for school parties
Great for lunchbox surprises
Easy to prepare ahead of time
They also make an adorable addition to a back-to-school dessert table or snack board.
Ingredients
To make these cute Pencil Wafer Cookies, you will need:
- Vanilla wafer cookies
- Pink candy melts
- Chocolate candy melts
- White or silver candy melts
- Parchment or wax paper
You will also need a small sharp knife to shape the ends of the wafer cookies.
How to Make Pencil Wafer Cookies
Step 1: Shape the Pencil Tip
Carefully cut one end of each vanilla wafer cookie at an angle on both sides to create a pointed pencil shape.
Because wafer cookies can be delicate, use a gentle sawing motion instead of pressing down too hard.
Step 2: Make the Pink Eraser
Melt the pink candy melts according to the package directions.
Dip the flat end of each wafer cookie into the melted pink candy, covering about half an inch of the cookie.
Place the dipped cookies onto parchment paper to set.
Step 3: Add the Pencil Lead
Melt the chocolate candy melts.
Dip just the pointed end of each wafer cookie into the melted chocolate to create the pencil lead.
Allow the chocolate to set.
Step 4: Create the Metal Eraser Band
Melt the white or silver candy melts and carefully add a thin strip between the pink eraser and the wafer cookie.
You can use a piping bag, a small zip-top bag with the corner snipped off, or simply drizzle it on with a spoon.
Let the cookies sit until all of the candy coating has hardened.
Tips for the Best Pencil Wafer Cookies
Work slowly when cutting the wafer cookies because they can break easily.
If the candy melts seem too thick for dipping, add a very small amount of coconut oil or shortening and stir until smooth.
For the cleanest results, allow each section to set before adding the next color.
You can also place the cookies in the refrigerator for a few minutes to help the candy coating firm up faster.
Fun Ways to Serve Them
These Pencil Wafer Cookies would be adorable for:
- First-day-of-school breakfast surprises
- Back-to-school parties
- Classroom celebrations
- Teacher appreciation treats
- School-themed birthday parties
- After-school snacks
- Lunchbox surprises
You could even package each cookie individually in a clear treat bag and tie it with ribbon for an easy back-to-school gift.
Make Them With the Kids
This is also a fun back-to-school activity to make together before school starts. Older kids can help dip and decorate the cookies, while younger children can help add sprinkles or arrange the finished pencils on a serving tray.
It is a simple way to build excitement for the new school year and create a sweet memory together.
How to Store Pencil Wafer Cookies
Store the finished cookies in an airtight container at room temperature for several days.
Keep them in a cool, dry place so the candy coating does not melt. If your kitchen is especially warm, you can refrigerate them, but allow them to come back to room temperature before serving for the best texture.
The Cutest Easy Back-to-School Snack
These Pencil Wafer Cookies prove that you do not need a complicated recipe to create an adorable back-to-school treat. With just a few ingredients and a little decorating, ordinary wafer cookies become the cutest edible pencils.
Whether you make them for your kids, a classroom party, or a first-day-of-school celebration, they are sure to bring some extra fun to the start of the school year.
Save this easy back-to-school snack idea for later, and find more simple recipes, kids’ activities, crafts, and family ideas at MommaReview.com.
